An unseeded Serena Williams drew world No. 70 Kristyna Pliskova on Thursday for the first round of the French Open. If she wins that matchup, she'll likely face No. 17 seed Ashleigh Barty. It could have been a lot worse.

While that draw in itself is relatively unremarkable, there's an argument that Williams should have been seeded, and that she was punished unfairly for taking time off the tour to have a baby.

Advertising

When Williams won the 2017 Australian Open, setting the Open-era Grand Slam record while eight weeks pregnant, she also became the world No. 1. To become a mother, she subsequently went over a year without playing an official match, letting her ranking fall outside the Top 400.

In her return, she's been allowed to enter tournaments on a protected ranking, meaning, for entry purposes, she's still treated as the No. 1. But, for seedings within the Roland Garros draw, she's considered the same as anyone else ranked below No. 32 seed Alize Cornet.

So, in theory, she could have had to face No. 1 Simona Halep in the first round. While the draw worked out fairly benignly for Williams, the overall spectacle has forced people to think seriously about what protections returning mothers should be afforded, and whether they deserve their seedings to be saved for them in addition to their rankings.

On one hand, there's the belief that a mother should never be disadvantaged at work for having a baby.

On its surface, this perspective is widely accepted.

Advertising

Even Ivanka Trump agreed.

Advertising

At the same time, by keeping a returning mother seeded, a player who has been fighting for 52 weeks for a high ranking would wind up losing out, as articulated by No. 15 seed CoCo Vandeweghe.

The French Open had the option to seed Williams, but elected to base seedings purely on WTA rankings. Wimbledon will be faced with making a similar decision in June. The WTA is also reviewing its rules on using special seeding for next season.

Advertising

Serena situation
provokes scrutiny of
seeding procedures

Serena situation provokes scrutiny of seeding procedures

—Tennis Channel Plus features up to 10 courts of live action from Roland Garros beginning Sunday, May 27 at 5:00am ET.

—Catch up and watch all your favorite stars anytime on-demand with Tennis Channel Plus.