Watching John Isner serve can create conflicting feelings in fellow tennis players, depending on which side of the court we imagine ourselves to be on. If you imagine yourself trying to return it, you might wonder, as so many of Isner’s opponent’s surely have, whether the rules of tennis are as fair as they might be. Should we really get two serves? Isner erases all of your hard work with one swing of his racquet. Even against players much more accomplished than he is, that shot alone allows him to remain in control at all times.
But if you imagine yourself serving, Isner shows you how easy the shot, which in reality is the game’s most complicated and difficult, can look. By the time he reaches up to smack the ball at its apex—what, nine, 10 feet in the air?—he appears to be halfway to the net already. From up there, it looks as if he can reach over and place the ball on the other side of the net, wherever he wants it to go.
On Friday morning, while waiting for a court at my tennis club, I watched Isner beat Robbie Ginepri in a rerun on Tennis Channel. The big man saved a match point at 4-5 in the third with an ace, held serve in that game with a second-serve ace that left Ginepri doubled over in frustration, and held for the match at 6-5 with four more aces. On the last one, Ginepri, shell-shocked, could only wave at a simple slice serve from Isner down the T. Isner broke Ginepri’s serve just once, but he broke his spirit with his own serve.
When I went out to play a few minutes later, unknowingly inspired by Isner, I found myself serving with a more relaxed motion. It worked, for a set anyway, and also made me wonder if I shouldn’t keep video clips of great shots—Isner’s serve, Federer’s forehand, Li Na’s backhand—with me to look at on changeovers.
Either way, tennis fans will probably be seeing quite a bit of Isner over the next five or six weeks. I know he’s not the most popular player around here. May I suggest, if you want to improve your own game, watching him serve—and then closing your eyes until the next point begins.