The cases of Gonzales and Rosewall are only the two most obvious. There were other greats might have captured more glory had the game been Open. Butch Buchholz was a Top 5 amateur when he turned pro the year he turned 20. Who knows what kind of victories he would have accumulated? The late Barry MacKay was the Goran Ivanisevic of his day, owner of a massive serve. Might MacKay have gotten so hot at Wimbledon one year that he would have taken the title? Spaniard Andres Gimeno also turned pro quite young and was such a formidable and fit player that he won Roland Garros at the age of 34 in 1972. On and on it goes.
Gracious as all the ex-barnstormers are, if you really want to make one grimace, ask how he felt whenever he would hear word of an amateur raising the trophy at Wimbledon.
“He was a fine player,” MacKay had told me about one such winner, “but I’ll tell you this: I really liked my chances against him.”
Off the court, the entire troupe hoped dearly that the ILTF would at last approve Open tennis. A painfully close moment came in 1960, when a motion to make that happen failed by five votes.
“I became a pro young, figuring I’d get a jump on Open tennis,” said Buchholz, whose tennis resume includes once playing 29 matches in 31 days in 30 cities. “But then it didn’t happen. It was frustrating.”
“Let me tell you something,” Segura once told me. “Sure, we wanted Open tennis. But right in front of me, every night, were a bunch of guys trying to take money out of my pocket. Of course, it was great to play in front of big crowds, or famous people, but when you get right down to it, a real player doesn’t care if anybody’s watching. He just wants to beat that guy.”
And even, on those rare occasions when an unscrupulous local promoter would surface, for not a single penny. If the legacy was long-term, such matters as the Gonzales serve, Hoad volley, and Rosewall backhand represented the here and now of a life spent circling the globe in pursuit of a little ball and a few extra hundred dollars a week.
The tipping point came in 1967. Herman David, chairman of the All England Club, had frequently attended a pro event held in London and always been struck by the gap in quality between the pros and the amateurs. Eager for Wimbledon to truly be the world’s premier tennis showcase, David in 1967 gave the green light for the Wimbledon World Pro Championships, an eight-man tournament to be played in late August at the All England Club. It was a smashing success, including color coverage on the BBC, a sparkling Gonzales win over Hoad and, fittingly, Laver beating Rosewall in the final.
David soon after proclaimed that in 1968, Wimbledon would be open to all. With tennis’ biggest domino toppling, the entire sport soon followed. The time had come for the barnstormers to cease burning candles and at last step into the spotlight.